In India’s rapidly growing electric vehicle (EV) market, compact EVs are gaining traction among urban commuters and environmentally conscious buyers. The MG Comet EV and Tata Punch.ev present two distinct approaches to compact EV design and functionality, offering a compelling comparison for potential buyers. On test, we have the MG Comet EV, priced at ₹9.99 lakh (top-spec Exclusive variant), and the Tata Punch. ev Adventure MR variant, which comes in at ₹11.69 lakh. With a price gap of ₹1.7 lakh, this review explores why the Punch. ev might be the smarter choice—even though it’s not a direct rival to the Comet. After all, when you consider the overall cost of buying a car, ₹1.7 lakh is about the price of a premium smartphone or a year of subscription services. Let’s dive in to see why this difference matters.

Why Compare the MG Comet EV and Tata Punch.ev?
At first glance, comparing the MG Comet EV to the Tata Punch.ev might seem unusual, as the Tiago EV is the Comet’s closest rival. However, stretching your budget slightly for the Punch.ev offers substantial benefits in terms of safety, utility, and performance. Both the Comet and Punch. ev cater to different kinds of buyers—the former prioritizing urban manoeuvrability and affordability, while the latter embodies a more well-rounded, practical, and versatile approach to EV ownership. Designed as a true SUV with cutting-edge technology, the Punch. ev raises the bar in its segment, making it an investment for those seeking more than just a city-centric EV.

Design Showdown: Quirky vs. Bold
The Comet EV grabs attention with its quirky, futuristic design. At just 2974 mm in length, it’s ideal for weaving through narrow streets. Sleek LED headlamps and a light bar ensure decent visibility, but the absence of DRLs, fog lamps, and LED projector headlamps—is standard on the Punch. ev—feels like a missed opportunity. The tiny 12-inch wheels and negligible road presence make it less suitable for highways or larger city roads. With only two doors, accessing the rear seats is inconvenient, and the minimal boot space limits its practicality.

The Punch.ev, on the other hand, boasts a bold micro-SUV stance, commanding attention with its muscular design. At 3827 mm in length, it exudes confidence, whether on highways or in city traffic. Premium features like LED projector headlamps, sequential turn indicators, and DRLs enhance its visual appeal. The four-door design ensures convenience, while the 366-litre boot makes it an excellent companion for family outings or long trips.

Powertrain and Range: Modest urban focus vs Versatile all-rounder
The Comet EV is equipped with a 42hp motor and a 17.3 kWh battery, offering a claimed ARAI range of 230 km (real-world range: ~190-195 km). It supports two driving modes—Eco and Sport—but lacks regenerative braking and DC fast charging. With a charging time of nearly 7 hours for 0-100% and 5.5 hours for 0-80% using a 3.3kW wall-box charger, the Comet EV may pose challenges for frequent or long-distance use.

The Punch.ev delivers a more powerful 120hp motor and a 35 kWh battery (Adventure MR variant), offering a claimed MIDC range of 365 km (real-world: ~290 km). It supports DC fast charging, drastically reducing downtime, and offers three driving modes—Eco, City, and Sport—that cater to various driving styles. Its advanced regenerative braking system enables one-pedal driving, providing greater efficiency and convenience in city conditions.

Safety Features: Basic vs Comprehensive
Safety is a critical aspect where the Punch. ev truly excels. The Comet EV offers basic safety features like dual airbags, ABS, and EBD, but lacks advanced safety enhancements. Its lack of a crash safety rating further raises concerns for buyers prioritizing family safety.

The Punch.ev, however, sets new standards in the compact EV segment. Equipped with six airbags, electronic stability control (ESC), and hill start assist, it provides comprehensive protection for its occupants. Features like all-wheel disc brakes ensure consistent braking performance. Additionally, its 5-star BNCAP safety rating reinforces its reputation as one of the safest vehicles in its category. Technologies such as a 360° surround-view camera and blind-spot monitoring further enhance situational awareness, making the Punch.ev an ideal choice for safety-conscious buyers.

Ride Quality and Handling: City Slicker vs All-terrain Champ
The Comet EV shines in urban environments, thanks to its compact size and a tight 4.2-meter turning radius. Navigating congested streets or tight parking spaces is effortless. However, its suspension struggles on uneven roads, resulting in a jittery and less composed ride.

In comparison, the Punch.ev is designed to handle a variety of terrains with ease. Its well-tuned suspension absorbs potholes and rough patches, delivering a smooth and comfortable ride. The SUV-inspired higher ground clearance ensures confidence over speed breakers, steep inclines, and rough roads. Whether navigating crowded urban streets or exploring rural areas, the Punch.ev feels steady and reliable. The addition of all-wheel disc brakes further enhances its braking performance, setting it apart in terms of ride quality and handling.

Is ₹1.7 lakh worth it?
While the Comet EV is priced attractively at ₹9.99 lakh, the Punch.ev Adventure MR variant justifies its ₹11.69 lakh price tag with superior safety, performance, and features. For ₹1.7 lakh more, you gain a powerful motor, advanced safety technologies, a larger battery with extended range, and a premium interior experience. The Punch.ev’s practical layout, SUV-inspired design, and robust build add further value, making it a better long-term investment.

Conclusion: A smarter choice for your EV journey
The MG Comet EV is undoubtedly an appealing choice for urban commuters seeking a compact, budget-friendly EV. Its quirky design and compact footprint make it a unique proposition for city-centric driving. However, the Punch EV redefines expectations in the compact EV segment by offering a versatile, feature-packed, and safety-oriented electric SUV experience.

For buyers seeking a true all-rounder, the Punch EV’s powerful performance, advanced safety features, and commanding road presence make it the superior choice. Whether it’s city commutes, family outings, or weekend getaways, the Punch EV is built to handle it all with ease. The ₹1.7 lakh price difference is a small premium to pay for a safer, more capable, and versatile EV.

In a market filled with compromises, the Tata Punch EV stands as a testament to what compact EVs can achieve, delivering exceptional value and making the decision refreshingly simple for discerning buyers.

Why compromise when you can have it all?
Tata Punch EV combines the best of style, safety, performance, and value. Whether you choose the Adventure MR or go all out with the Empowered+ S LR, you are getting an electric SUV that delivers far more than the competition. Starting at just ₹9.99 lakh, the Punch EV is the smarter, safer, and more stylish choice over the MG Comet. Do not settle for less when you can have the best—choose Tata Punch EV. Your journey deserves more.

Shot by: Anup Lakra for Drive Around the Globe